I have a ton of blogs in my reader. A ton.
I am a quick-fire subscriber. There, I admitted it.
However, it comes with its own drawbacks. One, being, that there is no possible way to read each one on a daily basis.
And at times, my favorites get lost in the pack, only to be rediscovered.
Which is what totally happened today.
Jaci over at Ravings of a Mad Housewife (who is awesome!), wrote a post that really struck a cord. And got me thinking.
Spanking.
Effective discipline?
If you asked me this a month ago or even a week ago, I would have given a definite thumbs up. I believe(d) spanking to be very effective in certain situations. Child runs into street, barely being missed by a passing car? During a shopping excursion, you turn your back for a split second and child is gone? In both these instances, spanking can be effective to quickly make you point on just how dangerous of a situation that can be.
But, and this is a fairly large but, I may have changed my mind.
You see, Chachi never really needed to be spanked. Of course, the above instances have happened and she did get a quick swat, but she was always my 'you hurt Mommy's feelings' regarding discipline child. Reasoning with her has, most times, worked much more effectively.
Even today.
Now, Stink on the other hand, is a different story.
As my Dad so lovingly says, "He is thick as a brick".
Lessons don't sink in. It is very hard to penetrate that brain of his. I'm not saying, by any means, that he isn't intelligent. Just the contrary. He is smart as a whip.
It's the things he could care less about that don't stay put in that tiny little head of his.
I guess you can call him....selective.
Take for instance, the refridgerator.
I can't count how many times he has been told to stay out. We even have a lock on it. Which lasted a good few days, until he found how to operate it.
One time, Dave got up at 4am to find Stink in the fridge sticking his finger in all the puddings.
4am!
So, after many many warnings and time outs, we resorted to spanking.
Which worked.
Temporarily.
He began to listen. Was heeding our warnings. I didn't need to say the same thing over and over and over again.
Now, remember when I say I may have changed my mind?
This is why.
We have had some pretty nice weather here these last few days. And all the neighborhood kids have been outside playing.
The other day, a couple older boys from up the street, maybe age 8 or 9, where a couple houses up fooling around.
Stink rides his scooter towards them. Hops off. And begins to chase them down yelling 'fight! fight! fight!'
To the point where they were running into the street to get away from him. He's two remember.
Of course, I called him back and disciplined him verbally.
After things settled down, I asked him why he did that.
Stink answered, "Because Mommy, they were bad and I needed to spank their butt."
I almost fainted.
Our 'disciplining method' just backfired.
How am I to explain to an almost 3 year old the difference between spanking and hitting others? How can I tell him how wrong it is to hit when I hit him?
Which is what I am left with. How?
What is your take on this debate?
And have you found a good alternative method?
For more opinions visit Jaci's comment section! Each offer great insight!